| Platinum | Bella Luna |
| Gold | H & W Drive-In |
| Silver | Toni's Courtyard Cafe & Bakery |
| Bronze | Gateway Pizza N Subs |
| Bronze | West Coast Sourdough |
| Top Pick | El Asadero Taco Shop |
| Top Pick | Jenny Nicole's Old School House Bakery |
| Top Pick | Mountain Mike's Pizza |
| Top Pick | Sam Cafe |
| Top Pick | Strings Italian Cafe |