| Platinum | Little Oven Pizza |
| Platinum | Tary Boscolo's Pizzeria & Italian Restaurant |
| Gold | Destino's |
| Silver | Bella Luna |
| Bronze | Table 59 |
| Top Pick | Lover's Deli |
| Top Pick | Lovers Deli |
| Top Pick | Pizza Guys |
| Top Pick | Runner Runner Pizza |
| Top Pick | Strings Italian Cafe |